Kill Goofy, a new play written by Eric Alter. Directed by David C. Neal. October 9-25, 2026 at the Grove Street Theatre, 130 Grove Street, Montclair NJ.

Kill Goofy – a new play by Eric Alter

We were inseparable. Until we weren’t.

Reserve Free – Pay at the Door

The Play

Freddy is forty-three, unemployed, and living in the same bedroom he grew up in, surrounded by the same Disney posters. His mother has met someone in Florida and is trying to work out whether she’s allowed to have a life. Barney, his best friend from childhood, is a psychologist in Ohio with a wife, a daughter, and a practice full of people who think he has the answers.

When they were thirteen, both boys were sexually abused by the same teacher. It became the biggest scandal the town had ever had. Barney’s family moved away. Freddy stayed.

Thirty years later Barney is back, and the two men finally have to face the strangest part of it: they were best friends the whole time, and they never told each other.

They told each other everything. Except one thing.
Same town. Same year. Same thing happened to both of them. The play asks which one of them actually survived it.

Nine Performances

Fridays & Saturdays 8:00 pm · Sunday matinees 1:30 pm

Reserve Your Seats

List everyone in your party, separated by commas. It helps us check you in at the door.

Before you reserve, please read.
Kill Goofy deals with the sexual abuse of two thirteen-year-old boys by an adult teacher. The play contains staged scenes of grooming, adult language throughout, references to suicide, and a scene in which a character describes an unwanted impulse toward a child. The sexual acts themselves are not depicted onstage. Recommended for ages 15 and up.
If you or someone you know needs support: 1in6.org · RAINN 800-656-4673 · 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline

You’re in.

A confirmation is on its way to your email with everything you need: where to park, how to pay at the door ($25 / $20 seniors & students, cash, Venmo or Zelle), and what to expect.

Prefer the phone? Reservations also taken at (973) 509-2350.

Good to Know

Tickets$25 general · $20 seniors & students. Reserve free online, pay at the door in cash, Venmo or Zelle. No credit or debit cards.
The Theatre360 seats, general admission, wheelchair accessible, free parking. 130 Grove Street, Montclair NJ.
Apricot Sky Productions
Original theater at the Grove Street Theatre, Montclair NJ, since 1999
Media: Beth Nydick · beth@bethnydick.com